J.Natn.Sci.Foundation Sri Lanka 2019 47 (2): 185 - 198 DOI: Mathematical model for malaria with mosquito-dependent 1 2* 3 4 1 Department of Mathematical Sciences, Baba Ghulam Shah Badshah, University, Rajouri, India. 2 Department of Mathematics, Lovely Professional University, Jalandhar, Punjab, India. Department of Mathematics, Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee, India. 4 Department of Mathematics, Govt. Post Graduate College, Rajouri, India. * shoketali87@gmail.com https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0383-7773) This license permits use, distribution and reproduction, commercial and non-commercial, provided that the original work is properly cited and is not changed in anyway. dynamics of malaria was proposed. In the model, mosquito population acts as the vector population and depends upon the human population for its growth and survival. It was shown that the environmental factors are conducive to the spread of malaria disease. It was also found that effective control programming against the spread of malaria is helpful in reducing the transmission dynamics of the disease. Sensitivity analysis was performed to show that spraying of pesticides and proper drainage system will effectively control the disease. Human and vector population, stability analysis, transmission dynamics. Malaria has become a worldwide problem and the 109 countries. Every year there are approximately 250 million cases of malaria reported, which result in one million deaths (WHO report 2013). transmission and several mathematical models have been formulated to investigate the transmission dynamics of malaria (Gupta et al et al et al et al Erin et al et al., 2013). Ngwa and Shu (2000) analysed a deterministic differential equation model for endemic malaria involving variable human and mosquito populations. Ngwa (2004) provided a solution by analysing the problem through the mathematical model. In the study the sample mathematical model has been considered and used a perturbation analysis and found that the death rate et al 2012) gave a model for infectious agents where they found the effect of immigration and disease induced death rates. The study of malaria transmission dynamics through mathematical modelling is a vast and fascinating area wherein the developed model depends on several a few areas like optimisation of malaria curing cost, role of awareness and follow-up cases, need to be researched. dependent on density. Mathematical models of the transmission of infectious agents in human communities Modelling of malaria epidemic has been carried out since et al. (2014) developed a mathematical model for malaria transmission among birds by changing vector behaviour. Fatmawati and Tasman (2015) studied a mathematical model for malaria transmission by considering the resistance of malaria parasites to the anti-malarial drugs and also incorporated mass treatment and insecticides 186 Ram Singh et al. June 2019 Journal of the National Science Foundation of Sri Lanka 47(2) model for assessing the impact of anti-malaria drugs on the transmission dynamics of malaria was designed and qualitatively analysed by Forouzannia and Gumel (2015). Wang et al model was developed to investigate the cause of the large abundance of mosquitoes in Guangdong province et al. (2017) developed a malaria model with an asymptomatic class in human population and exposed classes in both human and vector populations. The model assumes that asymptomatic individuals can get re-infected and move to the symptomatic class. Some of the developed models include density dependent death rates, environmental and other factors. However, in these dependent on the density of mosquitoes has not been considered. In this study, authors developed a susceptible, humans and a susceptible, exposed and infectious (SEI) model for mosquitoes and concluded that only human Many mathematical models have been developed earlier by many researchers on transmission dynamics of malaria disease, however the exposed class has not been taken into consideration. The exposed class is a where the disease has been transmitted to the human, but its symptoms have not yet appeared. We have incorporated an exposed class of humans in our model and analysed its effects on dynamics. Our model also considered an exposed class for mosquito population which is also an important component of the study. This has not been studied earlier studied (Singh et al In this model we assumed that there are two types of populations: (i) human population and (ii) vector (mosquito) population. The total number of individuals in the human population is denoted by N h which is further subdivided into the following four subclasses: (i) Susceptible human (S h ) (ii) Exposed human (E h ) (iii) Infected human (I h ) h ). It is assumed that people enter the susceptible class. When an infected mosquito bites the susceptible human, there may be more infected cases with some different moves to the recovered class. Once infected population is recovered, they return to the susceptible class. In this case total population is given as N h = S h + E h + I h h . Similarly, the total vector population is denoted by N v and subdivided into three classes viz. (i) susceptible mosquito (S v ), (ii) exposed mosquito (E v ) and (iii) infected mosquito (I v ). Susceptible mosquitoes are recruited at a rate 2 the exposed class and after some time there will be more infected moves from exposed class to the infected class. In this case N v = S v + E v + I v .The transmission diagram of malaria is depicted in Figure (1). For the mathematical formulation of the model, the following notations are used: 1 : recruitment rate i.e. 2 : recruitment rate of mosquito population which also includes newly A 1 : transmission probability rate from susceptible 2 : transmission probability rate from susceptible human to infected 3 : transmission probability rate 4 : transmission probability rate from susceptible vector h : progression rate from exposed class hE to infected class hI v : progression rate from exposed class vE to infected class vI : recovered : recovery rate for )( 21 dd : natural death rate of human population (mosquito population). d d d d d2 d2 d2 Rh Iv Ih Ev Sv Eh Sh h 1+ A 2 v 1ShEv + 2ShIv 3SvEh + 4SvIh Journal of the National Science Foundation of Sri Lanka 47(2) June 2019 The following two cases have been taken into account to formulate the mathematical model. We will analyse the model under two different cases mentioned below: The transmission probability, i.e. the rate 1 at which infected mosquito bites the susceptible human is assumed to be constant Transmission probability 1 is a function of density of the mosquito population. It takes the form 0101 bNbb v and is a positive constant. The model is governed by the following system of differential equations hhvvh h SdSIERA dt dS 1211 )()( hhhvv h EdSIE dt dE )()( 121 hhh h IdE dt dI )( 1 hh h RdI dt dR )( 1 11 h h NdA dt dN ...(01) vvhh v SdSIE dt dS 2432 )( vvvhh v EdSIE dt dE )()( 243 vvv v IdE dt dI 2 v v Nd dt dN 22 The developed mathematical model can be discussed in the following two cases: When 001 is a constant Since hhhhh NRIES and vvvv NIES then the system of equation (1) can be rewritten in the following form hhhhhhvv h EdRIENIE dt dE )())()(( 120 hhh h IdE dt dI )( 1 hh h RdI dt dR )( 1 11 h h NdA dt dN ...(02) vvvvvhh v EdIENIE dt dE )())()(( 243 vvv v IdE dt dI 2 v v Nd dt dN 22 The region of attraction of the above system is 0:),,,,,,{(1 hhhvvvhhhh RIENIENRIE }0, vvvvhh NNIENN where 1 1suplim and d A NN h t h 2 2suplim d NN v t v . Since we know that at equilibrium state all the derivatives vanish i.e. ,0 dt dN dt dI dt dE dt dN dt dR dt dI dt dE vvvhhhh then the system of equations (2) becomes 0)())()(( 120 hhhhhhvv EdRIENIE 0)( 1 hhh IdE 0)( 1 hh RdI 011 hNdA 0)())()(( 243 vvvvvhh EdIENIE 02 vvv IdE 022 vNd ...(03) 188 Ram Singh et al. June 2019 Journal of the National Science Foundation of Sri Lanka 47(2) The following are three physically as well as biologically relevant equilibrium points: (i) Disease free equilibrium for only the human population is 0,0,0,,0,0,0 1 1 1 d A E (ii) Disease free equilibrium for both human and mosquito populations 2 2 1 1 2 ,0,0,,0,0,0 dd A E (iii) Endemic equilibrium point is , ~ , ~ , ~ 3 hhh RIEE where, ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ vvvh NIEN , )( ~ ))(( 1 ~ 1 1112 2 0 2 2 0 hv hhv hv v h dE dddd NE d E ...(4) , ~ ~ 1d E I hh h , ))(( ~ ~ 11 dd E R hh h , ~ 1 1 d A Nh ...(5) , )( ~ 1 ~ ~ 2 11 4 3 1 4 3 vh vh vh h v dE dd NE d E , ~ ~ 2d E I vv v . ~ 2 2 d Nv ...(7) The equilibrium point 1E is stable if all latent roots are negative. The equilibrium 2E is stable if 0)4,2,1(ipi and ,)( 4 2 13213 pppppp and otherwise unstable. The equilibrium 3E is stable if 0)5,4,3,1(ii and ))(( 4 2 1 2 3 2 1321541 qqqqqqqqqq .)( 2 51 2 3215 qqqqqq The general variational matrix J corresponding to the system (2) is 2 2 4343243 20 43 1 1 1 202020120 00 0 )()()()( 000 000 000 0))(())(( 0000 0000 00))(())(( 000 0)(0 00)( )()()()()( d d IEIEdIE RIENRIEN IENIEN d d d IEIEIEdIE J v hhhhvhh hhhhhhhh vvvvvv h vvvvvvhvv 0,0,0,,0,0,0 1 1 1 d A E , the variational matrix 0J is given by 2 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 01 0 000000 00000 00)(0000 000000 0000)(0 00000)( 0000)( d d d d d d d A d A d J v v h h Journal of the National Science Foundation of Sri Lanka 47(2) June 2019 The characteristics polynomial of the Jacobian matrix is given by 0IJ )()()(())(( 111 2 21 hddddd 0))( 1 vd Hence all these roots are negative. Thus the equilibrium point 1E is stable. 2 2 1 1 2 ,0,0,,0,0,0 dd A E , the variational matrix 1J is given by 2 2 2 2 2 4 2 2 3 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 01 1 000000 00000 00)(00 000000 0000)(0 00000)( 0000)( d d d dd d d d d A d A d J v v h h The characteristics polynomial of the Jacobian matrix is given by 0IJ 0}){)()(( 432 2 1 34 121 ppppadd ...(8) where ,24321 daaap ,)( 3124324342322 vhNNdaaaaaaaaap )( 4124342324323 vhh NNdaaaaaaaaap ,)( 312231 vhvvh NNNNda ()( 42221243423224324 vhhddaaaaaadaaap ,)2322231 vhv NNada and )(),(),(),( 24131211 vh dadadada The three roots of the polynomial given by equation equation give all roots with negative real part. Hence 0)4,2,1(ipi and .)( 4 2 13213 pppppp For these conditions the equilibrium points 2E is locally asymptotically stable. vvhhhh IENRIEE , ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ 3 vN ~ , the variational matrix 2J is given by 2 2 4343243 20 43 1 1 1 202020120 2 00 0 ) ~~ () ~~ ()() ~~ ( 000 000 000 0)) ~~~ ( ~ ()) ~~~ ( ~ ( 0000 0000 00)) ~~ ( ~ ()) ~~ ( ~ ( 000 0)(0 00)( ~~ () ~~ () ~~ ()() ~~ ( d d IEIEdIE RIENRIEN IENIEN d d d IEIEIEdIE J v hhhhvhh hhhhhhhh vvvvvv h vvvvvvhvv 190 Ram Singh et al. June 2019 Journal of the National Science Foundation of Sri Lanka 47(2) The characteristics polynomial of the Jacobian matrix is given by 0IJ 0}){)(( 543 2 2 3 1 45 21 qqqqqdd ...(9) where ,26543211 daaaaaaq ))(())(( 264532162642 daaaaaaadaaq v ( 32513121 aaaaaaaa ,) 5318752 aaaaa h ()))((( 321626453213 aaaadaaaaaaq v () 513121521 aaaaaaaaa ))( 2645232 daaaaaa )( 541872121121387 aaaaadaa hv ),( 26415 daaaah )))((( 626452325131214 vadaaaaaaaaaaaaq ))(( 264521321 daaaaaaaa )( 2645h daaa ()( 21221138721121487 v dadaaaadaa 121aa )(() 264152221 hvv daaaaaa ))( 6264 vadaa )(()))((( 264562645213215 hv daaaadaaaaaaaaq () 2114876 v daaaa () 212138712 v daaaaa ))(() 6121645221 vhv aadaaaaaa and ),(),(),(),( 24131211 vh dadadada ),(),( 436205 hhvv IEaIEa )).(()),(( 87 vvvhhhh IENaRIENa of the above equation give all roots with conditions are: 0)5,4,3,1(ii and )( 541 .)()( 2 51 2 32154 2 1 2 3 2 1321 For these conditions the equilibrium points 3E is locally asymptotically stable. When 0101 bNbb v and 1b is a constant Since hhhhh NRIES and vvvv NIES the system of equation (1) can be rewritten in the following form vhhhhv h ERIENNbb dt dE ))()(( 10 hhhhhhv EdRIENI )())(( 12 hhh h IdE dt dI )( 1 hh h RdI dt dR )( 1 11 h h NdA dt dN vvvvvhh v EdIENIE dt dE )())()(( 243 vvv v IdE dt dI 2 v v Nd dt dN 22 ...(10) The region of attraction of the system given by equation (10) is 0:),,,,,,{(2 hhhvvvhhhh RIENIENRIE }0, vvvvhh NNIENN where 1 1suplim d A NN h t h and 2 2suplim d NN v t v . Since we know that at equilibrium state all the derivatives vanish Journal of the National Science Foundation of Sri Lanka 47(2) June 2019 i.e. ,0 dt dN dt dI dt dE dt dN dt dR dt dI dt dE vvvhhhh then the system of equations (10) becomes (())()(( 210 hhvvhhhhv ENIERIENNbb 0)()) 1 hhhh EdRI 0)( 1 hhh IdE 0)( 1 hh RdI 011 hNdA 0)())()(( 243 vvvvvhh EdIENIE 02 vvv IdE 022 vNd ...(11) The following are three physically as well as biologically relevant equilibrium points: (i) When the exposed human population is infected then the disease free equilibrium only for human population is 0,0,0,,0,0, 1 1 1 d A EP h (ii) When the exposed human population is infected only then the disease free equilibrium for both human and mosquito populations is 2 2 1 1 2 ,0,0,,0,0, dd A EP h (iii) Endemic equilibrium point is , ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ 3 hhhh NRIEP , ~ , ~ , ~ vvv NIE where , )( ~ ))(( 1 ~ 1 1112 2 2 2 10 1 1 2 2 2 2 10 hv hhv v v h dE ddddd bb d A E dd bb E ...(12) , )( ~ ))(( 1)( ~ )( ~ 1 1112 2 10 2 2 10 hv hhv v hv v v h dE dddd Nbb NE d Nbb E ...(13) , ~ ~ 1d E I hh h , ~ , ))(( ~ ~ 1 1 11 d A N dd E R h hh h ...(14) , )( ~ 1 ~ ~ 2 11 4 3 1 4 3 vh vh vh h v dE dd NE d E ...(15) . ~ , ~ ~ 2 2 2 d N d E I v vv v The equilibrium point 1P is stable if all latent roots are negative. The equilibrium 2P is stable if ,)(and0)4,2,1( 4 2 13213 mmmmmmimi otherwise unstable and the equilibrium 3P is stable if )5,4,3,1(isi 0 and )( 541 sss ( 2 3 2 1321 sssss .)() 2 51 2 32154 2 1 ssssssss 192 Ram Singh et al. June 2019 Journal of the National Science Foundation of Sri Lanka 47(2) The general variational matrix M corresponding to the system (10) is: 000 000 0))(())(( 000 )(0 0)( )()()()( 43 1 1 2102101210 vvvvvv h vvvvvvhvvv IENIEN d d IENbbIENbbdIENbb M 2 2 4343243 1 210210 000 00 )()()()(0 000 0000 0000 0))(())()(()( d d IEIEdIE d RIENRIENNbbIENbb v hhhhvhh hhhhhhhhvvvv 0,0,0,,0,0, 1 1 1 d A EP h , the variational matrix 0M is given by 2 2 3323 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 01 0 000000 00000 )(0000 000000 0000)(0 00000)( 0000)( d d EEdE d d d E d A E d A bd M v hhvh h hhh The characteristics polynomial of the Jacobian matrix is given by 0IJ 0]))())[(()()()()(( 322311121 vhvhh EddEddddd 0])( }){()[)()()()(( 3223 223 2 11121 vhvh vhh EddE ddEddddd and the other two roots are obtained by the quadratic equations. 2 2 1 1 2 ,0,0,,0,0, dd A EP h , the variational matrix 1M is given by Journal of the National Science Foundation of Sri Lanka 47(2) June 2019 The characteristics polynomial of the Jacobian matrix is given by 0IJ ){)()(( 2 2 1 34 121 mmadd 0}43 mm ...(17) where, ,24321 daaam 2322244342322 dadadaaaaaaam )( 32432 hv Edaaa ),)(( 103 hhvv ENNbbN )( 24342324323 daaaaaaaaam )()(()( 10223332 vvhv NbbdaNEaa ))( hh EN )(32 hhvv ENN ),)(( 104 hhvvh ENNbbN 32233224324 vhv NdaEaadaaam ))(( 23210 vvhhv NaENNbb )( hh EN ))(( 1024 hhvvh ENNbbNd ),(4 hhvvh ENN and ),(),(),( 131211 dadada h ).( 234 dEa vh The three roots of the polynomial given by biquadratic equation give all roots with negative are: )(and0)4,2,1( 4 2 13213 mmmmmmimi . For these conditions the equilibrium point 2P is locally asymptotically stable. vhhhh ENRIEP , ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ 3 , vvv NI ~ , ~ , the variational matrix 2M is given by 43 1 1 2102101210 2 000 000 0)) ~~ ( ~ ()) ~~ ( ~ ( 000 )(0 0)( ~~ ) ~ ( ~~ ) ~ ()( ~~ ) ~ ( IENIEN d d IENbbIENbbdIENbb M vvvvvv h vvvvvvhvvv 2 2 3323 2 2 4 2 2 3 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 2 2 101 1 000000 00000 )(00 000000 0000)(0 00000)( 0000)( d d EEdE dd d d d E d A E d A d bbd M v hhvh h hhh 194 Ram Singh et al. June 2019 Journal of the National Science Foundation of Sri Lanka 47(2) 2 2 4343243 1 210210 000 00 ) ~~ () ~~ ()() ~~ (0 000 0000 0000 0)) ~~~ ( ~ ()) ~~~ ( ~ )( ~ ( ~~ ) ~ ( d d IEIEdIE d RIENRIENNbbIENbb v hhhhvhh hhhhhhhhvvvv )),((),( 7436 hhhhhh RIENaIEa .)),(( 1098 vvvv NbbaIENa above equation give all roots with negative real part. 0)5,4,3,1(isi and )( 541 sss ( 2 3 2 1321 sssss .)() 2 51 2 32154 2 1 ssssssss Under these conditions the equilibrium point 3P is locally asymptotically stable. The global stability of the above equilibriums can be computed by constructing the Lyapunov function. The numerical simulation is presented to validate the analytical results discussed previously. For this purpose, the sensitivity analysis. The dataset for case 1 was as follows: ;0.00000029 =0 ;0.00000021 = 2 ;0.00000015 =3 ;0.00000009 =4 0.00012; =1d 0.0085; = 2d 0.00012; =1 0.0085; = 2 0.00146; = 0.0085;= 0.012; =1 12; =A 0.015; =2 and initial values were: 14000; = 20000; =209.2; = 4181.8; =500; = vhhhh IENRIE 963400. =30000; = vv NI , which are based on Gosh et al. (2005) and Hazarika and Similarly, for case 2, the parameters values are taken as follows: The characteristics polynomial of the Jacobian matrix is given by 0IJ 0}){)(( 543 2 2 3 1 45 21 sssssdd ...(18) where ,26543211 daaaaaas )(())(( 532162642 aaaaadaas v ())( 32513121264 aaaaaaaadaa ,) 5398752 aaaaaa h )))((( 626453213 adaaaaaas v ()( 513121521321 aaaaaaaaaaaa ())( 293872645232 daaadaaaaaa ) 5498729291 aaaaaaaa hv ),( 26415 daaaah ))((( 26452325131214 daaaaaaaaaaaas ))(() 2645213216 v daaaaaaaaa ()( 91294872645h aadaaadaaa () 9212922913872 v aaadaadaaaa )(() 264152221 hvv daaaaaa ))( 6264 vadaa )))((( 62645213215 vadaaaaaaaas ())(( 29148762645 vh daaaaadaaa )() 221292138712 vv aadaaaaaa ))(( 6121645 vh aadaaaa and ),(),(),( 131211 hdadada ,)(),( 210524 vvvv IENbbada Journal of the National Science Foundation of Sri Lanka 47(2) June 2019 0.00012; =0b ;0.000000061b ;0.00000021 = 2 0.000024; =3 000000009; =4 0.00012; =1d 0.0085; = 2d 0.00012; =1 0.00085; = 2 0.000146; = 0.012;= 0.012; =1 A 0.015; =2 10; =A and initial values were: 500; =hE 4181.8; =hI 209.2; = hR 20000; =hN 14000; = vE 30000; =v NI 963400. =vN which are based on Gosh et al. (2005) and Hazarika and The effect of progression rate h , on infected human population (I h ) is depicted in Figure 2. It is noted that initially when h is low the infected human population is also less, but as time increases the effect of h on I h is reversed. the I h decreases. 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 Time t h= 0.012 h= 0.008 h= 0.004 Variation in infective human population I h with time for various values of progression rate h , when the Time t 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 Time t = 0.0085 = 0.0135 = 0.0185 Variation in infective human population I h with time for Time t 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 5500 Time t = 0.00085 = 0.00135 = 0.00185 = 0.00235 Variation in infective human population I h with time for various values of the rate of immunity loss of recovered humans is a constant Time t 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 5500 6000 Time t A= 9 A= 14 A = 19 A = 24 Variation in infective human population I h with time for various values of immigration constant A, when the Time t 196 Ram Singh et al. June 2019 Journal of the National Science Foundation of Sri Lanka 47(2) h is shown in h increases with h increases with the increase in rate of immunity loss of recovered humans , which is illustrated in Figure 5. h is plotted against the various values of 1 susceptible humans and exposed mosquitoes. Increase in 1 , increases the I h . Whereas in Figure 7, I h is plotted against the various values of 2 which is the interaction mosquitoes. 2 also follows the same trend as 1 with respect to I h . The time-dependent patterns of infection and immunity are illustrated in Figure 8. With the increase 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 Time t 1=0.00000025 1=0.0000008 1=0.0000004 Variation in infective human population I h with time for 1 , between susceptible humans and exposed mosquitoes, when the 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 Time t 2=0.00000025 2=0.0000008 2=0.0000004 Variation in infective human population I h with time for 2 , between susceptible humans and infective mosquitoes, when the Time t Time t 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 -50 0 50 100 150 200 Time t v= 0.025 v= 0.015 v= 0.005 Variation in infective human population I h with time for various values of progression rate v , when the Time t 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000 16000 Time t Ih(t) Rh(t) Variation in infective population and recovered population humans is a constant. Time t Journal of the National Science Foundation of Sri Lanka 47(2) June 2019 and in the gradually decreases, due to the presence of non-linearity terms in the developed model. On the other hand, the proportion of recovered humans increases because of the fact that when some medicinal treatment is given to the infected human, its recovery rate grows Figures 10 and 11, show the variation in I h with respect to b 0 and b 1 population of humans increases with the increase in b 0 and b 1 . Variation in I h for two values of N v (t) (888.8, 1188.8) is given in Figure 12. It is noted that if N v is high then I h is also high. proposed by considering both human and mosquito populations. The exposed class of both human and mosquito populations were included. The major factor which is responsible for the spread of malaria is the and the infected mosquito. Numerical results revealed with immunity loss increases, then the number of infected humans increases, which are clearly illustrated in Figures 4 and 5. It has been concluded that effective control strategies against the malaria vector play an important role in the outburst of the disease. Proper drainage systems and insecticides can lead to elimination of mosquito population. Infectious Diseases of Humans. Oxford University Press. Oxford, UK. The Mathematical Theory of Epidemics, 1 = b 0 + b 1 N v is shown in Figures 9 to 12. In Figure 9 it is observed v decreases the I h increases. 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 -50 0 50 100 150 200 250 Time t b0=0.00012 b0=0.00008 b0=0.00004 Variation in infective human population I h with time for various values of b 0 humans is a variable Time t 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 -50 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 Time t b1=0.00000024 b1=0.00000018 b1=0.00000010 Variation in infective human population I h with time for various values of b 1 humans is a variable Time t 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 Time t Nv(t)= 888.8 Nv(t)= 1188.8 Variation in infective human population I h with time for various values of N v humans is a variable Time t 198 Ram Singh et al. June 2019 Journal of the National Science Foundation of Sri Lanka 47(2) Optimal control of a malaria model with asymptomatic class and super infection. Mathematical Biosciences 288: 94–108. DOI: model on malaria transmission. Bulletin of Mathematical Biology 73 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11538-010-9545-0 (2008). Malaria transmission pattern resilience to climatic variability is by insecticide-treated nets. Malaria Journal 7(100): 1–14. DOI: analysis of a mathematical model for malaria transmission. SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics 67(1): 24–45. DOI: mathematical model for the seasonal dynamics of malaria in mosquitoes. Bulletin of Mathematical Biology 74(5): 1098–1124. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11538-011-9710-0 malaria transmission through mathematical models. Trends in Parasitology 29(10): 477–482. to reduce the spread of malaria resistance. Mathematical Biosciences 262: 73–79. DOI: structured two-strain model for malaria transmission. Applied Mathematics and Computation 250 DOI: by changing vector behaviour. Journal of Theoretical Biology 358: 93–101. DOI: the spread of bacterial disease: Effect of service providers from an environmentally degraded region. Applied Mathematics and Computation 160 DOI: studies of the effects of heterogeneity in the parasite population on the transmission dynamics of malaria. Proceedings of the Royal Society B 256(1347): 231–238. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.1994.0075 model with time mosquito-dependent transmission co- Mathematical Sciences 121(1): 93– 109. Hethcote H.W. (2000). The mathematics of infectious diseases. SIAM Review 42 malaria transmission. Acta Tropica 49: 1–25. DOI: Li J. (2011). Malaria model with stage-structured mosquitoes. Mathematical Biosciences and Engineering 8 DOI: https://doi.org/10.3934/mbe.2011.8.753 malaria in growing populations. Discrete and Continuous Dynamical Systems B 4(4): 1173–1202. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3934/dcdsb.2004.4.1173 endemic malaria with variable human and mosquito populations. Mathematical and Computer Modelling 32 the study of a priori pathometry. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Series A 92 Macdonald model for malaria transmission. Bulletin of Mathematical Biology 70(4): 1098–1114. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11538-007-9292-z spread of malaria: environmental and ecological effects. Journal of Biological Systems 13(1): 1–11. mosquito model incorporating effects of precipitation and Journal of Theoretical Biology 411 DOI: World Health Organization (2013). Fact sheet. World Malaria . World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland. SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics 73(1): 351–373.