Cey. J. Sci. (Bio. Sci.), Vol. 24, No.2, 1995 CULTURAL, MORPHOLOGICAL AND PATHOGENICITY STUDIES ON SOME PHYTOPHTHORA ISOLATES FROM COCOA IN SRI LANKA M.A.P.K. Seneviratne*, A. De S. Liyanage4 Rubber Research Institute of Sri Lanka, Agalawatta and N.K.B. Adikaram Department of Botany, Faculty of Science, University of Peradeniya A detailed study was carried out on colony and sporangial morphology, growth characteristics, mating behaviour and pathogenicity of 110 Phytophthora isolates obtained from infected cocoa pods collected from different cocoa growing regions in Sri Lanka. The study revealed that about 95% of the isolates resembled Phytophthora palmivora morphological Form 1 and belonged to A2 compatibility. A small percentage (5%) was compatible with a known Ai type isolate. Isolates within locations showed significant variability in sporangial number, sporangial length/breadth ratio, pedicel length, chlamydospore number and their size. Variability in isolates in respect of sporangial length/breadth ratio and chlamydospore number was observed among locations. In general there was a variability in vitro growth pattern among isolates and also the lesion development on artificially inoculated pods. INTRODUCTION Cocoa (Theobroma cacao L), a native of the rain forest of Tropical America, has been grown in Sri Lanka primarily as an intercrop in rubber (Hevea brasiliensis Muell. Arg) in the districts of Kurunegala, Matale, Moneragala and Kandy. Intercropping generally provides an additional income and eases the financial burden of the grower during the long immaturity period of rubber which lasts for about 5-6 years before trees are brought into tapping. It also helps to arrest soil erosion especially where the terrain is steep, through the accumulation of leaf litter on the ground. However, one of the major constraints for intercropping rubber with cocoa is the possibility of damage caused by Phytophthora spp. that affect both rubber and cocoa. P. meadii arid P. palmivora have been identified as casual organisms of the Phytophthora disease syndrome of rubber, the former being the predominant species (Dantanarayana et.al. 1984). P. heveae (Thompson, 1929; Turner, 1968) and P. botryosa (Chee and Wastie, 1970) have been reported from both rubber and cocoa. Present address: * Department of Export Agriculture, Bambarakelle Housing Complex, Nuwara Eliya, Sri Lanka. ** Department of Primary Industries and Fisheries, Davonport/Tasmania 7310, Australia. 60 M.A.P.K. Seneviratne et al. 61 P. palmivora was known to be the fungus attacking cocoa wherever it is grown. Several morphological groups within P. palmivora have been identified (Orellana, 1959; Turner, 1960; Chee, 1969; Waterhouse, 1974a). Four morphological forms of P. palmivora have been recognised viz. MFi, MF2, MF3, and MF4 (Griffin, 1977). The isolates obtained from West Africa categorized as MF3 were identified as a new species P. megakarya (Brasier and Griffin, 1979). The isolates of MF4 collected from Central and South America resembled P. capsici (Kaosiri, 1978; Zentmyer et. al. 1979). Besides these P. citrophthora (Kellam and Zentmyer 1981) and P. katsurae are also pathogenic on cocoa (Liyanage and Wheeler, 1989). However, little information is available on the species, type and the distribution of Phytophthora species in Sri Lanka on cocoa, a prerequisite for recommending cocoa as an intercrop with rubber. MATERIALS AND METHODS Isolation of Phytophthora from cocoa Infected pods were surface sterilized in 70% alcohol and washed in several changes of sterilized distilled water. Small pieces (1cm2) were cut aseptically from the leading edge of the lesion and placed on 2.3% Lima Bean Agar plates (LBA, Difco). Pure cultures of Phytophthora thus obtained were maintained on LBA slopes under sterile liquid paraffin, at room temperature 28 ? 2?C. One hundred and ten isolates were obtained from cocoa growing districts of Sri Lanka viz. Matale, Kandy, Kurunegala, Badulla, Moneragala, Kegalle, Kalutara, Gampaha and Galle. Isolates were numbered serially, but separated by district of location as: Badulla B-l to B-18, Galle G-l to Gl-7, Gampaha Gm-1 Gm-8, Kalutara Kl-1 to Kl-9, Kandy Kn-1 to Kn-20, Kegalle Ke-1 to Ke-2, Kurunegala Ku-1 to Ku-13, Matale Ma-1 to Ma-23, Moneragala Mo-1 toMo-10. Growth rate and colony morphology on LBA A mycelial plug (4mm diameter) cut from the leading edge of an actively growing 3-4 days old culture was placed at the centre of a LB A plate. The plates were incubated at 28 ? 1 ?C in the dark At 24h intervals two measurements of colony diameter were taken at right angles to each other, each passing through the centre of inoculum plug. Four replicates were used for each isolate. For colony morphology studies cultures grown in total darkness for 6 days were examined against a black background. Colony morphology was assessed in terms of aerial mycelium and presence or absence of petaloid characters. Spnrangial morphology, dimensions and pedicel length Suspensions of sporangia were prepared by shaking mycelial plugs cut from 7-day-old cultures of LBA (grown in dark at 28?1?C) in distilled water. Drops of the suspensions stained with lactophenol/cotton blue were examined at a magnification of x 300. The sporangia! length and breadth and pedicel length of 25 sporangia from each replicate were measured using an eye piece graticule calibrated with a stage micrometer. Two replicates cultures were used for each isolate. Sporulation Isolates were grown for 7 days on 2 LBA plates at 28 ? 1 ?C in the dark as above. Eight mycelial plugs (4mm diameter) were removed from each plate from positions 1.5 and 2.5cm away from the centre of the colony. Each plug was placed in a drop (0.05 ml) of lactophenol/cotton blue on a slide which was subsequently heated gendy to melt the agar. A coverslip was placed over, the preparation by applying gentle pressure and the number of sporangia were counted in 3 randomly selected microscopic fields (magnification of x 300). Sporulation of each isolate was thus assessed in a total of 48 microscopic fields. Chlamydospore number and size Cultures prepared as above were incubated in the dark at 20?C for 1 month. Eight mycelial plugs (4mm diameter) were removed using a cork borer and the number of chlamydospores was assessed by the same procedure used above for counting sporangia. The diameter of 50 chlamydospores was measured from each replicate at a magnification of x 600. Two replicate cultures were used for each isolate. 62 Phytophthora in Cocoa Compatibility type To determine the compatibility type of the isolates, they were paired separately on LB A in the dark with a known Ai culture (P. meadii isolate No. 126 from rubber maintained at the Rubber Research Institute). These were left at room temperature, until mycelium of both isolates made contact with each other. The plates were subsequently transferred to a 20?C incubator and kept for a week before examination of plates for sexual reproductive structures. I Asinn development nn detached cocoa nods Healthy, green cocoa pods (about 15-18 cm long) were harvested carefully from a cocoa plantation having uniform plants of a single variety for artificial inoculation with Phytophthora isolates in the laboratory. The pods were arranged in metal trays lined with moist filter papers supported on glass rods. Mycelial plugs (12mm diam) cut from the leading edge of 7-day-old cultures grown on LBA at 28 ? 1?C in the dark were inserted into 1cm deep holes cut in the pod with a sterile 12mm cork borer. After inserting the mycelial plug the tissue disc removed was replaced. Three replicate pods were used per isolate tested. The trays containing the inoculated pods were covered with black polythene and incubated at room temperature (28?C). Commencing from two days after inoculation the developing lesions were traced onto a tracing paper for 3 consecutive days and the area of lesions was measured using a planimeter. RESULTS Colony growth of isolates Colonies of the 79 isolates cultured on LBA grew at different rates. Diameter of 6-day old colonies of the isolates tested ranged between 3-6cm. However, about 78% of the isolates attained colony diameters between 4-5cm after 6 days. In colony growth there was a significant interaction (P<0.001) between the isolate and time. It was not possible to give a common growth curve for all the isolates tested. It was also difficult to determine as to which isolate would have a common equation without examining the graphs of each isolate. Colony morphology on LBA Of the total number of isolates examined, 35% produced stellate colonies on LBA. The majority (about 56%) of the isolates, however, produced 'chrysanthemum' pattern colonies, while a few of them (B- 10,, Kl-6, Kl-7, Kn-16) produced colonies of broad petaloid type resembling the 'Rose' pattern. About 8% of the isolates produced 'uniform' colonies without distinct shapes. Eight percent of the isolates produced moderate to sparse aerial mycelium over the entire colony. Another 13% produced colonies with sparse aerial mycelium, while 8% of the isolates produced colonies with moderate aerial mycelium. Isolates No.Kl-3 and Kl-8 produced abundant to moderate aerial mycelium. The aerial mycelium of the rest of the isolates was mostly confined to the colony centre, though some isolates produced more aerial mycelium over the entire colony and grew particularly dense towards the centre. i ... Generally, isolates produced colonies with sharply defined leading edges while isolates Kl-7 and B- II produced wavy margins. The margins of the colonies of isolates B-12, B-13, Kl-4 were diffused. Sporangial morphology Most of the isolates produced sporangia with prominent papillae. These were mostly ovoid to ellipsoid in shape, the sporangia were often symmetrical, usually with a rounded base but sometimes with a slightly tapering base. Occasionally spherical sporangia and sporangia with two papillae were also seen. All the isolates produced sporangia with short, fairly broad and occluded pedicels. Sporangia were caducous in water. A small percentage of asymmetrically positioned pedicels were seen on some sporangia. In each isolate, sporangia without any obvious pedicel were also seen. Further all the isolates produced chlamydospores readily and freely on LBA, at 20?C. M.A.P.K. Seneviratne et al. 63 Compatibility types The isolates B-3, B-8, B-17, Mo-2, Mo-4 and Mo-8 produced sex organs when paired with a known A] compatibility type (Phytophthora meadii, isolate No. 126). However, even with these isolates only a very few oogonia were observed in cultures. The rest of the isolates did not produce any sex organs when paired with the Ai compatibility type isolate. Sporangia!, chlamvrinspnre and pedicel dimensions Seven parameters were considered, viz. sporangial length, sporangial breadth, sporangial length/breadth ratio, pedicel length, sporangia number, chlamydospore number and chlamydospore diameter, to study their variation at different locations (Badulla, Galle, Gampaha, Kalutara, Kandy, Kurunegala, Matale and Moneragala) and also their variation within a location. Mean sporangial dimensions and pedicel length of isolates obtained from different locations are given in Fig.l 3-5 MCD(/Am) 3 0 3-5 ? 3 - 0 M l ' U / i m ) 2-5 1-6 1-5 MSL IB \U 1-3 30 MSB(/Ok m)2o-i; .0-06 0 02 0 _ , 0 0 3 t 0 0 2 * ? ? 6 OLD ? 003 tO-011 t0-03 o 0 , 5 2 . 1 0 4 + 0 - 7 9 .0-74 I 0" 5 * K7 1O66 O U 10-69 tO-59 T i?H, . 0 8 7 t O - n '0-56 t1W .0-73 t 0 * 9 ,0-77 r ~ ] r~i B Gl Gm Kl Kn Ke Ku Ma Mo Location Fig.l. Mean sporangial length (MSL), Mean sporangial breadth (MSB), Mean sporangial length/breadth ratio (MS L/B), Mean pedicel length (MPL), Mean chlamidospore diameter (MCD) of isolated from different locations (B - Badulla, Gl - Galle, Gm - Gampaha, Kl - Kalutara, Kn - Kandy, Ke - Kegalle, Ku - Kurunegala, Ma ? Matale, Mo - Moneragala). A significant variation (P<0.001) was present between isolates within a location for all 7 variable studied. Also there were significant differences between locations on 5 out of 7 variables studied, viz. sporangial length (P<0.01), sporangial breadth (P<0.01), sporangial length/breadth ratio (P<0.001), pedicel length (P<0.05) and chlamydospore diameter (P<0.01). There were no significant differences (P<0.05) between locations on sporangia number and chlamydospore number. The range of mean sporangial length, mean sporangial breadth, mean sporangial length/breadth ratio, mean pedicel length and mean chlamydospore diameter were 45.14 ? 0.58 - 42.48 ? 0.87um, 29.91 ? 0.52 - 27.4 ? 0.74p.m. 1.59 ? 0.031 - 1.395 ? 0.029, 3.59 ? 0.26 - 2.73 ? 0.14pm, 39.99 ? 1.22 - 34.43 ? 0.77um, respectively. 64 Phytophthora in Cocoa The genetic type correlation among variables The genetic type coefficient of correlation among the 7 variables including colony diameter and mean lesion area were computed through the ANOVA using the between location component the ANOVA. These are not the usual "Environmental correlations" derived from the error component of the ANOVA, instead these correlations can be assumed to reflect relationships between any 2 variables, and be free of the environmental effect. Significant positive correlations were seen among the variables, sporangial length and sporangial breadth (P<0.001), sporangial breadth and pedicel length (P<0.05), sporangial length and square root of chlamydospore number (P<0.01), sporangial breadth and square root of chlamydospore number (P<0.001), sporangial length and colony diameter (P<0.01). These results show that when one variable increases the other also increases significantly. Significant negative correlations were observed between variables, sporangial breadth and sporangial length/breadth ratio (P<0.001), sporangial 1/b ratio and pedicel length (P<0.05), sporangial length and square root of sporangia number (P<0.01), pedicel length and chlamydospore diameter (P<0.01) chlamydospore diameter and colony diameter (P<0.001) and square root of sporangia number and lesion area (P<0.05). Lesion develqpment on pods inoculated with different isolates When the isolates were inoculated into pods and incubated they developed lesions characteristic to black pod disease in cacao. The rate of lesion expansion varied among isolates. Lesion growth by different isolates showed strong evidence of a positive linear effect of the rate of growth. The rate of increase in the lesion size is constant over the 3 days considered. But this constant seemed to vary with the isolates as shown by a significant (P<0.001) interaction between isolates and day in the linear component. DISCUSSION The pedicel length of the sporangium has been widely accepted as a stable character having a high diagnostic value in the identification of Phytophthora species (Waterhouse, 1974 b; Griffin, 1977; Tsao, 1977; Tsao and Tummakate, 1977; Zentmyer et al. 1977). This character has also been found stable under different environmental conditions (Kaosiri, 1978). In a previous study Dantanarayana et al. (1984) has shown that the pedicel length is a criterion that separates Phytophthora species in rubber from those of cocoa in Sri Lanka. The isolates tested in this study produced caducous sporangia with short, broad pedicels less than 5 u in length. There was a variability in the pedicel length of isolates between different locations. The isolates thus resembled P. palmivora morphological form 1 in pedicel length, occluded nature of the pedicel, caducous sporangia with short (<5um) and broad pedicel as given in the key of Newhook ei al (1978). The caducity has been well recognized as a taxonomic character dividing species of Phytophthora into two groups, one with caducous and the other with persistent sporangia (Waterhouse 1974b; Al- Hedaithy and Tsao 1979; Saleh et al 1979). Brasier and Griffin (1979) examined the colony morphology of S-type isolates of P. palmivora from both cocoa and other hosts and showed considerable variation within the type which were nonetheless highly characteristic, although a subjective character. Most of the isolates we studied were stellate and chrysanthemum with sharply defined leading edges. This provides further evidence for identifying these isolates as P. palmivora. Brasier and Griffin (1979) also observed that the aerial mycelium of S-type (P. palmivora MFi) was sparse, being more or less absent from the peripheral areas of the colony but more in the centre. Similar results were obtained from the present study too. Sporangial length/breadth ratio has often been used as a taxonomic parameter in P. palmivora (Ashby, 1929, Turner, 1960,1961, Chee, 1969, Waterhouse 1974 a), but is liable to alter with different environmental conditions (Ashby, 1929, Leonian, 1934). In P. palmivora the 1/b ratio is always >1.4 on a standard medium. Most commonly the 1/b ratio is 1.6 and may extend upto 2.0 or more (Waterhouse, 1974 a). In the present study the 1/b ratio of all the isolates were >1.4 and most were around l.S confirming that the isolates belong to the species, P. palmivora MFi. The production of chlamydospores was a useful character in the separation of P. medii from P. palmivora, the latter producing chlamydospores freely under all conditions (Dantanarayana et al. 1984; Waterhouse, 1963). The production of chlamydospores by all the isolates is also a useful parameter in identification of isolates as P. palmivora. M.A.P.K. Seneviratne et al. 65 Liyanage and Threemanna (1982) studied 22 isolates of P. palmivora from different cocoa plantations of Kandy and Matale Districts and found that they were of A2 compatibility type. Later Bandara et. al. (1985) who examined Phytophthora isolates from cocoa in Kandy and Matale Districts concluded that the isolates were MFi type of P. palmivora and belonged to the A2 mating type. However, Zentmyer (1974) has reported the presence of both Ai and A2 types in Sri Lanka on cocoa. During the present study mainly the A2 type was found among the cocoa isolates collected from different locations, with a small percentage of Aj compatibility type. A significant variation was observed in the sporangial length, sporangial breadth, sporangial l/b ratio, pedicel length, sporangia number, chlamydospore number and chlamydospore diameter within a location. Among the isolates tested these characters varied between locations. This indicates that there is a high variability among isolates. It is also important to note that eventhough there is a significant variation in sporangial number and chlamydospore number in a location, this does not vary significandy between locations. When the genetic type correlation between the variables explained above and the colony diameter and mean lesion size produced on cocoa pods are considered, there is a highly significant positive correlation between the sporangial length and the sporangial breadth. This explains that when the sporangial length increases in an isolate, sporangial breadth also increases proportionately. There is no correlation between the sporangial length and l/b ratio, but there is a highly negative correlation between sporangial breadth and l/b ratio. This explains that the contribution of the length of a sporangial to l/b ratio is negligible when compared to that of the sporangial breadth. The "isolate x day" interaction on colony growth, shows variability of growth patterns of different isolates. The slow, medium and fast growing isolates can be seen in each location indicating the variability of growth rate in isolates of a location. On inoculation into cocoa pods all the isolates produced symptoms characteristic of black pod disease in cocoa. The rate of increase in the lesion size was constant over the three days, for individual isolates but varied with different isolates, indicating that the pathogenic ability was different among isolates. Further in laboratory inoculation studies these isolates produced lesions on the leaves, petioles and the pods of rubber. However, the fact that this compatibility type has never been isolated from rubber indicates that such infections do not take place in nature. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This work was supported by a grant from the Rubber Research Institute of Sri Lanka. The authors thank Professor J.M.R.S.Bandara and Dr (Mrs) N.LS. Liyanage for their help in this study. REFERENCES Al-Headaithy, S.S .A and Tsao, P.H. (1979). Sporangium pedicel length in Phytophthora species and the consideration of its uniformity in determining sporangium caducity. Trans. Br. Mycol Soc. 72: 1-13. Ashby, SF. (1929). Strains and taxonomy of Phytophthora palmivora Butler (P. Faberi Maubl.) Trans. Br. Mycol. Soc. 14: 18-38. Bandara, J.M.R.S., Chandrasena, G. and Abeykoon, A.M.D. (1985). Compatibility and pathogenicity Phytophthora palmivora (Butl.) on hosts of high intensity cropping systems in the up country of Sri Lanka. Sri Lankan Journal of Agricultural Sciences 22(1): 39-48. Brasier, CM. & Griffin, M.J. (1979). Taxonomy of Phytophthora palmivora on cocoa. Trans. Br. Mycol. Soc. 72: 111-143. Chee, K.H. (1969). Variability of Phytophthora species from Hevea brasiliensis. Trans. Br. Mycol. Soc. 52: 425-436. Chee, K.H. and Wastie, R.L. (1970). Black pod disease of cocoa. Planter, Kuala Lumpur, 46: 294-297. ' Dantanarayana, D.M., Pedes, O.S. and Liyanage, A. de S. (1984). Taxonomy of Phytophthora species isolated from rubber in Sri Lanka. Trans. Br. Mycol. Soc. 82(1): 113-126. 66 Phytophthora in Cocoa Dantanarayana, D.M., Peries, O.S. and Liyanage, A. de S. (1984). Taxonomy of Phytophthora species isolated from rubber in Sri Lanka. Trans. Br. Mycol. Soc. 82(1): 113-126. Griffin, MJ. (1977). Cocoa Phytophthora workshop, Rothamsted Experimental Station, England. Pans, 23: 107-110. Kaosiri, T. (1978). Morphological, Taxonomic and cytological studies of Phytophthora palmivora. Ph.D thesis, University of California, Riverside, 148 pp. Kaosiri, T., Zentmyer, G.A. and Erwin, D.C. (1978). Stalk length as a taxonomic criterion for Phytophthora palmivora isolated from cocoa. CanJ.Bot. 56:1730-1738. Kellam, M.K. and Zentmyer, G.A. (1981). Isolation of Phytophthora citrophthora from cocoa in Brazil (Abstr.). Phytopathology, 71: 230. Leonian, L.H. (1934). Identification of Phytophthora species. W. Va. .Agric.Exp.Stn.Bull. 262: 36. Liyanage, A. de S. and Threemanna, S. (1982). Annual Review of the Rubber Research Institute of Sri Lanka. 1982,. 64-65. Liyanage, N.I.S. and Wheeler, B.E.J. (1989). Phytophthora katsurae from cocoa. Plant Pathology (1989), 38: 627-629. Newhook, FJ., Waterhouse, G.M. and Stamps, DJ. (1978). Tabular key to the species of Phytophthora de Bary. Mycol.pap. 143. Common W.MycolInst., Kew Surrey, England, 20pp. Orellana, R.G. (1959). Variation in Phytophthora palmivora isolated from cocoa and rubber. Phytopathology, 49: 210-213. Saleh, S.A., Al-Hedaithy and Tsao, P.H. (1979). Sporangium pedicel length in Phytophthora species and the consideration of its uniformity in determining sporangium caducity. Trans. Br. Mycol. Soc. 72(1): 1- 13. Thompson, A. (1929). Phytophthora species in Malaya. Malayan Agric. J. 22,369-371. Tsao, P.H. (1977). Importance of Sporangium caducity, pedicel length and ontogeny in Phytophthora speciation (Abstr). Proceedings of Second International Mycoloigcal Congress, Tampa, Florida, p.678. Tsao, P.H. and Tummakate, A. (1977). The identity of a Phytophthora species from black pepper in Thailand. Mycologia, 69: 631-637. Turner, P.D. (1960). Strains of Phytophthora palmivora (Bult.) Bult. from Theobroma cocoa, L, Isolates from West Africa. Trans. Br. Mycol. Soc. 43: 665-672. Turner, P.D. (1961). Complementary isolates of Phytophthora palmivora from cocoa and rubber and their taxonomy. Phytopathology, 51: 161-164. Turner, P.D. (1968). Pod rot of cocoa in Malaysian caused by Phytophthora heveae. Pl.prot.Bull.FAO, 16: 33. Waterhouse, G.M. (1963). Key to the species of Phytophthora de Bary. Mycol. Pap.92, Commonwealth Mycological Institute, Kew, Surrey, England, 22pp. Waterhouse, G.M. (1974 a). Phytophthora palmivora and some related species. In Phytophthora disease of cocoa, (ed. P.H.Gregory) pp.51-70. London: Longman. Waterhouse, G.M. (1974 b) Other species of Phytophthora recorded on cocoa. In Phytophthora disease of cocoa (ed. P.H.Gregory) pp.71-79. London: Longman. M.A.P.K. Seneviratne et al. 67 Zentmyer, G.A. (1974). Variation, Genetics and geographical distribution of mating types. In Phytophthora disease of cocoa (ed. P.H.Gregory), pp.89-102. London: Longman. Zentmyer, G.A., Kaosiri, T. and Idosu, G. (1977). Taxonomic variants in the Phytophthora palmivora complex. Trans. Br. Mycol. Soc. 67: 329-332. Zentmyer, G.A., Kaosiri, T., Idosu, G.O. and Kellman, M.K. (1979). Morphological forms of Phytophthora palmivora. In paper presented at the 7th International Cocoa Research conference 1979. Douala, Cameroon (Abs.)